ec magazine subscriptions are now avalible online!
Home
EC Magazine Fall 2005
Fall 2005



Favorite Flavors

A new study reveals that horses love bananas and … fenugreek?

by Tracy Williams

As a horse-owner, you have probably personally witnessed your horse separate carefully-blended powdered medication from the grains of his feed or watched him nibble every last shred of leaf before eating the hay stalks. Obviously horses can taste different nuances of flavor and prefer some over others. In a new study, British researchers took this knowledge a step further and discovered that out of 15 options, the studied horses preferred to munch banana and fenugreek over other flavors.

Several historical research trials indicate horses crave variety; in the wild, they will consume up to 50 types of forage as they roam and graze throughout the day. According to Deborah Goodwin, head researcher of the new study, many horses experience "dietary monotony" through domestication. For simplicity's sake, feeding limited feed varieties is practical in most horse settings; even with turnout, most horses can't wander far enough to eat an extensive range of feeds. In fact, horse owners avoid diet changes because a sudden shift in feed type could result in gastric upset; the horse's digestive system is prone to problems. However, providing your horse with some flavor variety might be the key to tempting a finicky appetite, camouflaging medications or preventing unwanted behaviors such as weaving or cribbing. In this study, researchers discovered two flavors that may be keys to unlocking those doors.
A Series of Trials
Goodwin and a team of researchers chose 15 potentials historically and currently used to flavor horse feeds all over the world: apple, banana, carrot, cherry, coriander, cumin, echinacea, fenugreek, garlic, ginger, nutmeg, oregano, peppermint, rosemary and turmeric. Eight horses participated in a series of preference tests over three trials to discover which of these flavors was preferred. They determined rankings by measuring the quantity consumed, consumption time and any partial rejections or refusals of the flavors.

In the first trial, one gram of each powdered flavor was mixed with 100 grams of plain cereal by-product, in addition to free-choice hay and a morning feeding of the unflavored grain. Six flavors were presented per day, separated by an hour in between each test, and the tests were replicated. From this initial trial, researchers eliminated echinacea, nutmeg and coriander after they were rejected by three horses. The other twelve flavors were accepted by every horse, but researchers only chose the eight fastest consumption times to continue to trial 2. In the second trial, the eight flavors were paired off and presented simultaneously in separate feed tubs to the eight horses. Fenugreek, banana, cherry, rosemary, cumin, carrot, peppermint and oregano were the top ranking flavors in that order. In the third trial, the winning flavors fenugreek and banana were further tested. Here researchers experimented by seasoning mineral pellets instead of the cereal by-product with these two flavors. Not only did the horses overwhelmingly prefer the flavored pellets but banana edged out fenugreek for the top-ranking taste of the study.
Rosemary Photo by Donna rae Moratelli
Bananas and Fenugreek
Bananas may initially seem like an odd food for a horse, yet they are not as uncommon as you might think. In other countries bananas are a staple treat - like apples and carrots in this part of the world. "In India horses are often fed bananas. And my horse's dentist told me recently that one of his clients feeds her old horse with very poor teeth 4-5 bananas a day, and it maintains excellent condition," said Goodwin who lives in the United Kingdom. Nutritionally, bananas are rich in potassium and high in energy; they also contain high levels of phospholipids that can help line the stomach and protect against gastric ulcers. For these reasons, during the Olympic Games in Sydney, bananas were a favorite treat and diet component for horses from seven countries.

Although bananas sound slightly strange, fenugreek sounds completely exotic. It is an herb, traditionally used to flavor Indian curries and other foreign dishes. According to equine herbalist, Victoria Ferguson, fenugreek was historically used as a hay conditioner for Greek horsemen, and currently in the horse world, it is used in herbal supplementation. "Horses find the aroma of fenugreek attractive, and it is therefore an excellent herb to stimulate the appetite while at the same time being a tonic to the liver and digestive system. Therefore, it helps to promote balanced feed conversion and improve general body condition," Ferguson said. According to Ferguson, fenugreek also cleanses the lymphatic system, protects mucus membranes and can be given in conjunction with other herbs to promote sweating in horses suffering from anhydrosis.
Bananas - Photo by Jostein Hauge
Fenugreek - Photo courtesy of Department of Primary Industries © State of Victoria, Department of Primary Industries 2000

Your Horse's Favorites?

While these two flavors won out in this particular study, they are probably not universal for every horse. It may take a bit of experimenting to discover what your horse loves best. Before adding anything to his feed, however, contact a qualified nutritionist or veterinarian to avoid causing more harm than good. Furthermore, beware drastic diet changes lest you upset the delicate digestive balance, but consider introducing new flavors in small doses. They can have benefits. In previous studies, Goodwin demonstrated that horses presented with several feed varieties didn't exhibit negative stall behavior such as cribbing or weaving. In addition, seasoning your horse's feed may tempt his finicky appetite and encourage weight gain or help you disguise medications from his clever senses. At the very least, you can introduce novelty by providing an occasional, nutritious treat. "Owners may like to learn more about what their own horses' preferences are by offering small amounts of novel flavors," Goodwin said. "However, responsible owners will be aware of the risks of making sudden large changes to the bulk of the horse's diet."

In the newest study on flavor preferences in horses, researchers found that out of 15 options, horses preferred banana, fenugreek, cherry and rosemary flavors in that order.
Cherries Photo by Edyta Pawlowska
Reference:
Goodwin, D.; Davidson, H.P.B.; Harris, P. (2005) Selection and acceptance of flavours in concentrate diets for stabled horses. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 95, 223-232, 2005.

The Flavors of Choice
Tempt your horse's appetite with the fragrant blends in Spillers Meadow Herb feeds. These products contain eight herbs: balm, fenugreek, garlic, parsley, spearmint, red clover, rosemary, and sage. In the latest flavor preference study, researchers tested the effects of fenugreek, rosemary, spearmint and garlic and discovered that these flavors significantly increased palatability of feeds - especially fenugreek, the second most preferred flavor in the study. The new line of Meadow Herb now includes three options: Spillers Meadow Herb Cool Mix, Competition Mix or Senior Mix. Now, more than ever, your horse can enjoy the fragrant and tasty Meadow Herb blends.

Learn more about Spillers Meadow Herb Feeds...
Meadow Herb Horse Feed


Meet the Experts
Dr. Deborah Goodwin
Victoria Ferguson,
Equine Herbalist

Dr. Deborah Goodwin is the head researcher in the recent flavor preference study. She holds a degree in Zoology from the University College of Wales and a PhD in Equine Parasitology from the University of Southampton where she researched equine behavior and ecology in the transmission of parasitic infections.

In addition, she spent nine years investigating social and feeding behavior of horses, cats and dogs at the School of Biological Sciences at Southampton. Currently she holds a lectureship position at the University of Southampton in Applied Animal Behavior, but she is also actively pursuing several research projects. Her current research interests include human-animal interactions, enrichment for captive animals including stalled horses, equine behavior and cognition, as well as several others.
Victoria Ferguson grew up in Central Queensland and started riding in shows at 5 years old. She has been addicted to horses ever since. She has competed successfully with hacks, showjumpers, eventers, campdrafters and dressage horses.

With her Grand Prix dressage partner Gamekeeper, She was selected on the long list for the Australian team to the 1990 World Championships. She is an Equestrian Federation of Australia Level 2 Dressage Coach, which includes a Certificate of Horse Studies. Victoria has a Diploma of Herbal Medicine, having completed her herbal medicine training with Dorothy Hall, the eminent Australian herbalist & author. She is also the author of the best selling handbook for horse owners, The Practical Horse Herbal.
Tracy Williams, a native New Mexican, recently graduated from Colorado State University with degrees in both Equine Science and Journalism. For the time being, she is the new editorial intern at ec while she contemplates moving permanently to Florida and leaving the Western mountains and chile behind.



Seminole Feed
World's Best Feed
335 Northeast Watula Ave., Ocala, FL 34470, editor@ecmagazine.net
Visit our affiliate sites www.seminolefeed.com and www.worldsbestfeed.com and www.spillerssemniole.com

© Seminole Feed and ec magazine 2004 - 2006. All Rights Reserved.